How to choose a software development company for your next project
Сhoosing the right software development company is crucial for achieving your business objectives, as the company you pick becomes not just a service provider — but a resource, a partner, and essentially an extension of your team. The challenge? Sifting through the multitude of options to find the perfect match.
With two decades of experience in software development consulting under our belt, we're here to help you navigate the tricky process of choosing the right vendor. We'll help ensure they align with your project goals, adhere to your timelines, and remain within budget through precise software project estimation.
Plus, we'll empower you with the insights to identify a capable and reputable company, along with what pitfalls to dodge.
First off, define your project's needs and goals
Clearly understand
Clearly understand your project's goals, scope, timelines, and primary objectives. A well-defined project plan keeps everyone on the same page and facilitates effective communication, enhancing the likelihood of meeting milestones on time.
A thorough plan lays out a clear roadmap with checkpoints, enabling timely adjustments and alignment with business goals. This improves team productivity and fosters better collaboration, contributing to the project's overall success.
Before you dive into the vendor pool, answer the following questions. (Make sure to clarify the scope and estimates first, as it will make the process much easier.)
-
Are you building your team and product from the ground up, or do you already have a team requiring additional support?
-
Can you outline the current makeup of your team, their expertise, and the technology stack in use?
-
What expertise or technology is your team lacking?
-
Do you require temporary or ongoing assistance?
-
What budget have you allocated for this project?
Where to find software development vendors
While there is no shortage of vendors in the software industry, identifying one that aligns with your project requirements isn't always straightforward. Here are a few helpful tips and common pitfalls to avoid:
Do:
-
Request recommendations from your partners
-
Browse Google business profiles that have a significant number of client reviews
-
Search business marketplace websites like Clutch, Capterra, G2, and DesignRush. Target industry leaders and companies with excellent reviews
-
Search LinkedIn for reputable vendors with experience working in your specific industry
-
Look up software and technology awards in your industry, like the IAOP Global Outsourcing 100 Award, and Global Business Excellence Award
-
Evaluate the company’s profiles, services, and areas of expertise
Don’t:
-
Don’t rely on rankings from non-reputable sites
-
Get recommendations on web forums, as users may be associated with the companies they recommend
Check out a software vendor’s portfolio
Be sure to do your homework regarding your vendor’s past projects, as it enables you to better assess their domain-specific experience and success with similar projects.
This analysis is key to choosing the best tech stack for your project and finding a vendor with deep insights into your industry's specific challenges.
Here’s why domain know-how matters:
-
Proven competence: As you explore how to choose the right software development company, past projects serve as a tangible demonstration of the vendor's ability to deliver quality work. They offer insights into the company's proficiency in various technologies and methodologies.
-
Understanding of industry standards and challenges: Vendors with domain-specific experience are familiar with your industry's unique challenges and regulatory standards, which are particularly important in highly regulated industries like fintech and healthcare. This results in more efficient problem-solving and innovative solutions tailored to your project’s needs.
-
Risk mitigation: A track record of successful projects in your domain indicates competency and reduces the risks associated with project delivery. It indicates that the vendor knows how to navigate common pitfalls and deliver superior results on time and within budget.
-
Cultural and operational fit: Review past projects to understand the vendor's project management style and communication practices and determine if they will be a cultural fit with your organization.
-
Efficiency and speed: Vendors with experience in your industry have a reduced learning curve, resulting in accelerated completion times.
Assess a vendor’s track record of project success
01. Request detailed case studies
Look for case studies or portfolio examples that closely match your project type, industry, and tech requirements. Pay attention to the challenges faced, the solutions implemented, and the data demonstrating the real, quantifiable results achieved (say, a boost in new customer acquisition, faster time-to-market, or fewer bugs).
02. Check client testimonials
Speak with previous clients in your industry about their experience with the vendor. Get their assessment of the vendor's strengths, weaknesses, and ability to deliver on time and budget.
03. Evaluate technical expertise
Ensure the vendor has expertise in the specific technologies, platforms, or frameworks required for your project. Look for certifications, awards, or recognitions that prove their technical capabilities.
04. Assess domain knowledge
Make sure the vendor really understands your industry’s challenges, trends, and regulations. You can figure this out through direct questions, discussions, or by checking out their blogs, white papers, and presentations on topics relevant to your field.
05. Consider the complexity of past projects
Gauge the vendor’s ability to handle your project by analyzing the complexity and scale of previous projects. Projects that demonstrate high complexity and successful management under challenging conditions are a good indicator of competence.
06. Engage in technical and strategic discussions
Have deep technical and strategic talks to see how well they grasp your project goals and how they can use their experience to help you meet them.
07. Look for innovation and problem-solving skills
Evaluate the vendor's ability to think outside the box and solve problems creatively. Vendors with a track record of innovative solutions in past projects will likely bring fresh perspectives and inventive approaches to your project.
Assess company culture and partnership approach
When figuring out how to choose the right custom software development company, prioritize cultural compatibility. It's essential to partner with a vendor that resonates with your business culture and values, as it ensures seamless communication, efficient workflows, and a foundation of mutual respect.
Look for indicators like "Great Place to Work" awards, the vendor's staff retention rates, and community involvement, which can highlight a positive, supportive company culture. Also, pay close attention to how well you mesh with the prospective vendor in your early interactions and discussions.
|
Enhanced communication |
When both parties share similar communication styles and values, misunderstandings are less likely to occur, which makes the project management process run smoothly. This alignment also helps clearly define expectations, milestones, and feedback loops. |
|
Increased trust and collaboration |
When a vendor shares your company's values, they are more likely to go the extra mile. This shared commitment fosters a strong sense of trust and collaboration, which is critical to overcoming challenges and adapting to changes in the development process. |
|
Improved project outcomes |
A partnership built on shared values and culture usually leads to higher-quality outcomes. Both teams work more cohesively when they agree on a project's goals and the broader impact. |
|
Long-term relationship |
Cultural and value alignment contribute to building a long-term relationship. It paves the way for future collaborations and can become a long-term partnership. |
|
Employee satisfaction |
Working with a vendor that respects and mirrors your cultural practices improves your team's satisfaction and morale (read: productivity). |
Stick to the rule of similar-sized companies
The "rule of similar-sized companies" advises that businesses should seek partnerships with companies of comparable size. This rule is based on the idea that companies of similar size often have aligned resources, goals, and challenges, allowing them to work together as seamlessly as dancers in perfect sync.
Such similarities typically lead to smoother collaborations and more balanced partnerships, where power dynamics are equitable, and both parties can foster mutual respect and understanding. Moreover, these partnerships help ensure that both parties receive appropriate attention and priority, avoiding scenarios where disparities in size could lead to mismatched expectations or unequal prioritization.
Additionally, companies of similar sizes often share cultural and organizational similarities, leading to better compatibility.
Important: While this rule can help businesses foster more synergistic relationships, successful partnerships can also occur between companies of different sizes with clear communication and shared objectives.
Ensure a collaborative and transparent partnership
|
Communicate your values
Clearly articulate your company’s core values and cultural attributes from the outset. This will help you filter and find vendors that mirror your organizational ethos, facilitating a smoother selection process. |
Assess cultural fit
Make cultural fit a cornerstone of your vendor selection process. Discuss the vendor's working style, values, decision-making processes, and team dynamics. |
|
Look for flexibility
Choose a vendor that shows flexibility in adapting to your project needs and communication styles. Such adaptability is vital for effectively navigating unexpected challenges and project evolutions.
|
Establish open lines of communication
Set up regular check-ins and feedback sessions to ensure ongoing, open communication. Use collaborative tools like project management calendars that align with both parties' preferences to facilitate seamless interaction. |
|
Jointly develop a project charter
Create a charter or agreement that outlines the vision, objectives, roles, responsibilities, communication protocols, and conflict resolution mechanisms. The document's purpose is to serve as a foundation for your collaborative efforts. |
Encourage team integration
Promote interactions between team members from both companies through joint workshops, team-building activities, or casual meetups. These interactions help synchronize teams culturally and operationally. |
|
Monitor and adjust
Regularly assess the health of the partnership through surveys, feedback, and regular review meetings. Be open to adjusting communication styles, processes, or project goals. |
Promote transparency in decision-making
Cultivate trust through transparency by openly discussing project challenges, scope changes, or issues. Engage in joint problem-solving and ensure all decisions are made collaboratively. |
Vendor location: onshoring, offshoring, or nearshoring?
The decision between onshoring, offshoring, and nearshoring should be determined by your project's specific requirements, budget, and strategic goal. Carefully consider each approach's trade-offs in cost, communication, and collaboration.
|
Attribute |
Onshoring |
Offshoring |
Nearshoring |
|
Cost |
Typically higher due to additional HR costs, company benefits, and dismissal costs |
Lower due to reduced labor costs in offshore locations |
Balanced (generally lower than onshoring, but higher than offshoring) |
|
Cultural alignment |
High (shared language and cultural norms usually simplify communication) |
Variable (potential cultural and language barriers can impact communication) |
Generally high, with more cultural similarities than offshoring |
|
Time zone compatibility |
High, as working in the same or similar time zones facilitates real-time collaboration |
Low, as significant time zone differences can complicate scheduling and real-time collaboration |
High, as similar time zones make real-time communication easier |
|
Talent pool access |
Dependent on local talent availability, which may be limited in certain areas |
Access to a broad global pool of skilled professionals |
Access to talent is generally good, but niche skill availability can be scarce |
|
Regulatory compliance |
Easier to comply with local laws, regulations, and standards |
Increased complexity in navigating foreign legal and regulatory environments |
Typically easier than offshoring, but still requires consideration of foreign laws |
|
Communication |
Generally easier due to time zone alignment and the same language |
Often challenging due to language barriers and time zone differences (note, however, that particular remote locations might actually be closer in terms of culture and language than some nearshore locations) |
Easier than offshoring due to fewer language barriers and closer time zones |
|
Risk factors |
Lower risk due to easier communication and simpler legal compliance |
Higher risk due to cultural, legal, and time zone differences |
Medium risk (balances the risks between onshoring and offshoring)
|
Technical expertise and specialization
Understanding how to choose a custom software development company involves a critical evaluation of the technical abilities of your potential vendors. This ensures that your project benefits from the most efficient execution and the best available tools and methodologies.
Here’s why choosing a company with specific tech expertise is essential:
-
Expertise in specific technologies ensures that the software will perform well and meet the expectations and demands of users.
-
Companies proficient in the required tech stack can work more efficiently, which translates to faster development times and potentially lower costs.
-
Vendors who are experts in their technological domains are positioned to write scalable, maintainable code adaptable to future projects or updates to existing software.
-
If a prospective vendor excels in emerging technologies like blockchain, AI, and VR, it suggests their ability to offer innovative solutions that enhance competitiveness and future-proof your project.
How to evaluate technical skills and tech stack
01. Request a technical proposal
Ask the vendor to provide a technical proposal for your project. This should include their approach, the technologies they plan to use, and how they intend to address your project’s challenges.
02. Ask for a code review
If possible, ask for a code review session to see the quality and clarity of the vendor’s code and ensure it’s maintainable long-term.
03. Evaluate their development methodologies
It's crucial to understand the vendor's development methodologies, like Agile, Scrum, or Waterfall, to ensure they align with your project's needs. (For instance, Waterfall might not fit well for projects requiring flexibility and frequent iterations.)
04. Evaluate their contribution to open-source:
Investigate whether the vendor actively contributes to open-source projects, which is often a testament to their technical skills and commitment to technology advancement.
05. Technical interview or Q&A session
Consider arranging a technical interview or Q&A session with the vendor's technical team to gauge their knowledge and expertise directly.
06. Ask for developer profiles
Ask for resumes or profiles of the developers assigned to your project. Some vendors, like Vention, allow you to interview these candidates personally, offering a deeper evaluation of their skills and experience.
07. Evaluate their technological ecosystem
Beyond the specific technologies required for your project, understand the vendor's overall technological ecosystem, including their tools for project management, version control, and CI/CD practices, as well as how they maintain code quality and security.
Communication and project management
Consider your vendor partnership like building a house, with communication and solid project management as the base. Effective communication and strong project management practices are vital to any software development project's success, efficiency, product quality, and overall satisfaction of all stakeholders.
|
Effective communication |
Project management practices |
|
Use visual aids: Incorporate diagrams, flowcharts, and other visual tools to improve the accessibility of information. |
Utilize Agile methodologies: Implement agile methodologies that focus on iterative progress, flexibility, and continuous feedback. |
|
Cultural sensitivity: When dealing with international teams, adapt communication to respect cultural differences. |
Performance metrics: Establish clear performance metrics for monitoring project progress and team productivity. |
|
Proactive issue reporting: Encourage a culture where team members report potential issues before they become significant problems. This proactive approach saves time and resources. |
Stakeholder engagement: Develop a stakeholder engagement plan that includes regular updates and involves them in decision-making processes when appropriate. |
|
Tailored insights: Customize communication strategies to fit the preferences and roles of different stakeholders. For example, tech details may be more relevant to the development team, while strategic impacts are crucial for executive stakeholders. |
Learning and development: Foster an environment of continuous learning and improvement. Encourage team members to upgrade their skills and knowledge through workshops, courses, and seminars on project management and tech skills. |
Extra tips on how to assess a vendor’s project management methodology
01. Integration with existing systems
Ensure the vendor can integrate their project management tools with your internal systems for efficient data flow.
02. Discuss frequency and types of updates
Understand how often the vendor provides project updates and the level of detail included. Regular updates and check-ins should be baked into their process.
03. Conflict resolution protocols
Investigate the vendor’s methods for managing conflicts or disagreements, highlighting their problem-solving capabilities.
04. Custom reporting capabilities
Verify if the vendor offers customizable reports to meet your project monitoring needs.
05. Resource management
Evaluate how effectively the vendor allocates and manages resources — crucial for keeping the project on track and within budget.
06. Innovation in project management
Explore any innovative practices or tools the vendor uses, such as AI for predictive analytics.
07. Escalation mechanisms
Understand the procedures for escalating critical issues to ensure quick resolution.
08. Knowledge management
Check how the vendor captures and distributes project knowledge essential for ongoing improvement and learning.
Security and intellectual property
Curious how to choose a secure software development company? Easy: Start by ensuring they excel in data security, confidentiality, and intellectual property (IP) protection. These considerations protect your business's sensitive information and ensure compliance with legal and industry standards.
|
Data handling and security Understand how the vendor handles and secures sensitive or personally identifiable data. This includes data encryption, secure data transfer methods, and storage solutions. |
Confidentiality measures The vendor should have strict confidentiality measures, including similar measures in non-disclosure agreements (NDAs) with their employees and subcontractors. |
|
Intellectual property rights Clear agreements on IP rights are crucial. Establish who owns the IP for development work, code, documentation, and related materials. |
Compliance with standards and regulations Make sure the vendor adheres to applicable industry standards and regulations, such as the GDPR for data protection in Europe, HIPAA for health information in the US, or ISO 27001 for information security management. |
|
Access control Strict access control ensures that only authorized personnel can access sensitive information. |
Audit trails and monitoring The capability to monitor and log access and changes to data is critical for quickly detecting and mitigating unauthorized activities. |
|
Incident response plan The vendor should have a robust incident response plan to detect and address data breaches or IP theft. |
Ongoing security training The vendor's staff should receive regular training on the latest security practices and compliance requirements. |
Post-deployment support and maintenance
Ongoing support, maintenance, and future scalability are aspects of software development that can significantly impact a project's long-term success and viability. After the initial launch, software often requires continuous updates to address new challenges, improve features, and maintain security.
Ongoing support and maintenance needs include:
|
Ensuring operational stability |
Regular maintenance helps identify and fix bugs, performance issues, and vulnerabilities that could affect the software's stability and security. |
|
Adapting to technological advances |
Software must evolve to leverage new technologies and frameworks that can improve efficiency, security, and user experience. |
|
Enhancing features and functionality |
Based on user feedback and market trends, ongoing support allows for the addition of new features and enhancements to keep the software competitive. |
|
Security updates |
With cyber threats always present and evolving, regular updates to software security are crucial to protect against vulnerabilities. |
Post-launch services, updates, and support
Don’t get stuck with a vendor who will leave you high and dry post-launch. Discuss and understand their approach to ongoing support, maintenance, and scalability. Consider asking about:
|
Service Level Agreement (SLA)
SLAs define the scope, quality, and timelines for ongoing support and maintenance services. |
Dedicated support teams
Dedicated support teams handle post-launch issues, ensuring resources are available to address problems or requests that arise. |
|
Continuous integration and continuous deployment (CI/CD)
Adopting CI/CD practices can streamline the development, testing, and deployment, making the process more efficient and less prone to errors. |
User feedback loops
Establishing channels for user feedback is crucial for identifying areas for improvement and prioritizing future updates. This can include support forums, feedback widgets, and regular user surveys. |
|
Version control and update rollouts
Companies typically manage software updates through version control systems, with the option for phased rollouts to monitor impact and catch issues early. |
Security patch management
Regularly scheduled security audits and promptly deploying patches to address vulnerabilities are standard practices. |
Cost considerations and contract negotiation
Define a budget and pricing models that suit you best
|
Fixed price
Fixed price works best for projects with well-defined scopes. Fixed pricing provides certainty on project costs but allows minimal flexibility for changes. |
Time and materials
This approach offers flexibility should the project's scope, requirements, or duration change; costs are calculated based on the actual work performed. The choice between time and materials vs. fixed price often hinges on how flexible your scope is. |
|
Value-based pricing
Pricing is set according to the value the project is expected to deliver to the client, considering potential customer spending on the product or the projected revenue savings for the company. This model encourages vendors to focus on providing maximum value. |
Retainer or subscription
Clients pay a set fee monthly or yearly to keep a vendor retained. Ideal for ongoing projects where regular maintenance or updates are needed.
|
Lifehacks for selecting a vendor that fits your budget
-
Clearly define project scope and deliverables: Clearly outline project goals, scope, and timelines to eliminate ambiguity, prevent misunderstandings, and ensure contract terms align with project objectives.
-
Establish milestones and payment schedule: Link payments to completing specific milestones. This arrangement confirms that progress is consistent with the agreed-upon timeline.
-
Include flexibility for changes: Since requirements and project scopes sometimes shift, be prepared to adjust pricing if significant changes occur.
-
Negotiate ownership and IP rights: Define who will own intellectual property upon project completion.
-
Outline quality and performance metrics: Lay out specific, measurable criteria for evaluating performance and quality of work delivered. Also, include remedies for non-compliance.
-
Plan for contingencies and exit strategies: Develop a contingency plan for potential project cancellation, failure to meet critical milestones, and inadequate performance. Specify any penalties or settlement terms.
-
Consider a pilot project: For larger projects, starting with a smaller pilot project offers an excellent opportunity to evaluate a vendor's capabilities and refine project estimates before launching a full-scale partnership.
How to hire a software development company: comparison grid
* Disclaimer: This comparison is for reference purposes only, may not fully capture all characteristics, and reflects only typical ones. All claims and data are based on available resources and should be independently verified for accuracy and relevance. Information in this comparison is subject to change without notice.
Vention
No-code app builders
In-house development
Full-service digital agencies
Talent marketplaces (Toptal, Upwork, etc.)
Companies similar to Vention
We offer a range of engagement models tailored to your unique needs:
No code, no sweat: You usually get a plug-and-play app development solution that requires zero (or minimal) technical skills
In-house development offers direct project control, yet smaller and mid-size firms still often depend on employer-of-record services for managing operations
A complete set of digital marketing and web development services (software development rarely included in offerings)
-
Usually operate on a project-by-project basis
-
Hourly, part-time, and full-time engagements are typically offered
-
Can take your pick: a few freelancers to integrate with your established teams or a full-fledged squad built upon your request
-
Staff augmentation
-
Project outsourcing
-
Dedicated teams
-
Product-oriented delivery (pods)
-
Additional services may vary depending on the company's offerings
One of the most extensive lineups of partnerships in the industry:
AWS, Google Cloud Platform, Salesforce, Stripe, UiPath, HashiCorp, Microsoft AI Cloud Partner
Depends on a company
Year after year, we receive the most prestigious tech awards:
Inc. 5000, Globee Awards: Disruptor Awards, Financial Times, Stevie, IAOP Global Outsourcing 100
More common for larger software service providers
ISO 27001
Depends on a company's quality standards
Option to interview developers to ensure the perfect team fit
Ongoing employee training
Internal hackathons and meetups
Partnerships with top universities for sourcing emerging tech talent
Knowledge-sharing initiatives
Customized development plans aligned with company strategy
As a Great Place to Work-certified™ company, we prioritize the well-being and satisfaction of every employee across all functions, levels, and locations
Toptal
Upwork
We easily scale teams up or down, replace engineers for optimal fit, and adjust team skill sets as needed
In most cases, yes
Low, as proven by 20+ years in the market and hundreds of five-star ratings
Middle
High
Low
High
Low
Red flags when choosing the right software development company
What are tips for choosing a software development partner to help you avoid common pitfalls? Watch out for these red flags when assessing potential vendors:
Lack of relevant experience: If a vendor cannot demonstrate experience with projects of similar size and complexity to your requirements, it likely lacks the necessary expertise.
Poor communication: Effective and timely communication is crucial for any project. Be cautious of vendors who are slow to respond or lack clarity, especially during the initial interview.
No clear development process: A reliable software development vendor is a well-oiled machine with a clearly defined development process. A lack of clear methodologies can lead to project delays, poor quality control, and budgetary pitfalls.
Questionable business practices: Signs of unethical or questionable business practices, such as avoiding direct answers, changing terms frequently, or not providing an NDA right away, should raise suspicion.
Lack of references, reviews, or testimonials: References, testimonials, and reviews from satisfied clients speak to a prospective vendor's quality of work and reliability. Reluctance or inability to provide proof of customer satisfaction can indicate poor quality work or lack of experience.
Excessive focus on (low) price: While an affordable price tag is tempting, vendors that emphasize their low rates excessively may compromise on quality.
Vague or incomplete proposals: Proposals should clearly outline the scope of work, deliverables, timelines, and costs. Vague or incomplete proposals are a recipe for misunderstandings and disagreements down the road.
Inflexibility: Project needs can shift and evolve. You need a vendor who can adapt. Inflexibility can be a sign of a challenging collaboration ahead.
Ignoring project management and quality assurance: Vendors that put project management and quality assurance processes on the back burner may be unable to deliver a project on time and within the agreed-upon budget.
Lack of technical expertise: To ensure seamless integration with your existing team, ensure the prospective vendor is proficient in the platforms, software, and technologies you use. A lack of technical skills or reliance on outdated technologies can hinder a project’s success.
How to choose a software development company: the checklist
With so many factors to weigh, picking the right vendor can seem daunting. To help you out, we've put together a simplified checklist.
Experience and expertise: Verify the company has experience with projects similar in size, complexity, and industry.
Portfolio and case studies: Review the company’s portfolio and case studies to assess whether their quality of work is acceptable.
Client references: Request and verify references from previous clients to gauge their satisfaction with the vendor’s quality of work.
Technical skills: Ensure the vendor has expertise with the technologies and tools your project requires.
Cultural and value alignment: Assess whether the company’s culture and values align with yours to ensure a smooth collaboration.
Communication style: Evaluate their communication practices to ensure clarity, responsiveness, and compatibility with your preferred methods.
Development process: Understand their development process and methodologies to ensure they match your project’s needs.
Project management: Understand their project management tools and practices.
Quality assurance: Learn about their quality assurance procedures, testing, and how they address bugs or issues.
Pricing model: Be on the same page regarding the pricing model, including the type of pricing structure, and understand the cost of time and materials, etc.
Cost transparency: Ensure transparency in costs, including any additional fees or unexpected expenses that may arise.
Budget alignment: Verify that their cost estimate aligns with your budget without compromising quality.
Contracts and agreements: Carefully review contracts for clarity on service types, scope, deliverables, timelines, IP rights, and other key terms that are important to you.
Data security and confidentiality: Assess their practices around data security, confidentiality, and ability to help with compliance with your industry's regulations.
Post-launch support: Discuss and understand their approach to maintenance, support, and future scalability.
